CBSE vs ICSE for a child who is bright but not very exam-oriented

Harini V

We are choosing between nearby IB and State board schools. Our child loves stories and projects but gets bored with repetitive worksheets. Parents who have experienced both systems, what differences did you notice in everyday workload rather than brochure claims?

7 comments

  • Manoj Kumar

    We asked what happens when a child is struggling, not just what happens to top performers. The answer told us more about the school culture than the brochure did. The commute piece changed our final shortlist more than expected. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

  • Nupur Chatterjee

    We asked what happens when a child is struggling, not just what happens to top performers. The answer told us more about the school culture than the brochure did. My spouse had a different view initially, so we tried it for a few weeks before deciding. The commute piece changed our final shortlist more than expected. We only reached that conclusion after trying the other approach first.

    • lj4769

      That makes sense. I think consistency is the part we are currently missing. For us, the admission office answer and the parent answer were not always the same. We made the change gradually rather than all at once.

  • Suresh Babu

    We asked what happens when a child is struggling, not just what happens to top performers. The answer told us more about the school culture than the brochure did. The biggest surprise was that the practical routine mattered more than the option that looked best on paper. I would still verify it with the school for the current academic year. Your child's response may be different, but this was our experience.

    • hv1403

      This is close to what my spouse is suggesting too. I may have been overcomplicating it. We found this out only after doing a second school visit. We only reached that conclusion after trying the other approach first.

    • Padma Priya

      This is close to what my spouse is suggesting too. I may have been overcomplicating it. The commute piece changed our final shortlist more than expected. We made the change gradually rather than all at once.

    • sj3622

      Thanks for saying this. Online advice often makes normal family life sound much more organised than it really is. For us, the admission office answer and the parent answer were not always the same. We are in Bengaluru, so local logistics may be a little different.

    • Arun Raj

      Can I ask roughly what age/class your child was when you tried this? For us, the admission office answer and the parent answer were not always the same. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

    • Ramesh Iyer

      Thank you. I like that this does not require changing everything at once. I wish we had asked this before paying the registration amount. Your child's response may be different, but this was our experience.

    • bn3994

      Thanks for saying this. Online advice often makes normal family life sound much more organised than it really is. The commute piece changed our final shortlist more than expected. We only reached that conclusion after trying the other approach first.

    • Priyanka Bose

      Replying to @bn3994

      Good to know — thank you for coming back with the detail. We found this out only after doing a second school visit. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

  • ho5838

    We asked what happens when a child is struggling, not just what happens to top performers. The answer told us more about the school culture than the brochure did. I wish we had asked this before paying the registration amount. In our house, the practical routine mattered more than the ideal plan.

    • Aditya Narayan

      Interesting — we had assumed the opposite. Helpful to hear a first-hand experience. I would still verify it with the school for the current academic year. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

  • if0744

    We asked what happens when a child is struggling, not just what happens to top performers. The answer told us more about the school culture than the brochure did. The commute piece changed our final shortlist more than expected. Your child's response may be different, but this was our experience.

    • Harini V

      This is useful, thank you. The practical detail is exactly what I was looking for. We found this out only after doing a second school visit. We are in Hyderabad, so local logistics may be a little different.

  • fu9374

    We asked what happens when a child is struggling, not just what happens to top performers. The answer told us more about the school culture than the brochure did. I wish we had asked this before paying the registration amount. We are in Hyderabad, so local logistics may be a little different.

  • mh4278

    Do a second visit on a normal working day if the school allows it. Open-house days can feel very different from the everyday atmosphere. Our child reacted better once we explained the change in advance instead of announcing it on the day. For us, the admission office answer and the parent answer were not always the same. In our house, the practical routine mattered more than the ideal plan.

Add a comment

Share what happened for you. Plain text; be kind and specific.