Career counsellor in Class 10: useful or mostly generic reports?

Arun Raj

School offers a paid aptitude package and there are many private counsellors too. If you used one, what made the session genuinely useful? I do not need a report that simply says 'good at analysis'.

16 comments

  • Srinivas M

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. Current students gave us more useful detail than the institute presentation. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

    • uv2689

      Interesting — we had assumed the opposite. Helpful to hear a first-hand experience. Current students gave us more useful detail than the institute presentation. We made the change gradually rather than all at once.

  • Mohan Krishna

    Try to let the student own the shortlist while parents own the budget/deadline guardrails. That split worked well for us. We revisited the plan after a few months instead of treating it as irreversible. We only reached that conclusion after trying the other approach first.

    • ed3892

      This helps. I am going to add this to the questions for our next visit/meeting. Seeing the actual weekly timetable made the trade-off much clearer. We made the change gradually rather than all at once.

    • ui9254

      This is useful, thank you. The practical detail is exactly what I was looking for. We separated the child's preference from the family budget conversation. We made the change gradually rather than all at once.

    • Kavya Srinivas

      Could you share what you would do differently if you were starting again? Current students gave us more useful detail than the institute presentation. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

  • cu6712

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. Our child reacted better once we explained the change in advance instead of announcing it on the day. We revisited the plan after a few months instead of treating it as irreversible. Your child's response may be different, but this was our experience.

  • Nitin Saxena

    A backup plan actually reduced pressure in our house. The child could aim high without feeling one exam would decide their whole future. The biggest surprise was that the practical routine mattered more than the option that looked best on paper.

  • Asha Thomas

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. We are in Thrissur and this came up for us last year.

    • Arun Raj

      This is close to what my spouse is suggesting too. I may have been overcomplicating it. Seeing the actual weekly timetable made the trade-off much clearer. In our house, the practical routine mattered more than the ideal plan.

    • Priyanka Bose

      Thanks for saying this. Online advice often makes normal family life sound much more organised than it really is. We also kept a backup option so one exam did not feel like the whole future. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

    • dt9155

      This helps. I am going to add this to the questions for our next visit/meeting. We separated the child's preference from the family budget conversation. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

  • Arvind Menon

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. The biggest surprise was that the practical routine mattered more than the option that looked best on paper.

    • Amit Bansal

      Thanks for saying this. Online advice often makes normal family life sound much more organised than it really is. We revisited the plan after a few months instead of treating it as irreversible. We only reached that conclusion after trying the other approach first.

  • Siddharth Kapoor

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. We separated the child's preference from the family budget conversation. We are in Delhi, so local logistics may be a little different.

    • Arun Raj

      Thank you. I like that this does not require changing everything at once. We also kept a backup option so one exam did not feel like the whole future. In our house, the practical routine mattered more than the ideal plan.

  • zv5311

    Please be cautious of any institute promising guaranteed ranks. Speaking to current students gave us a much more realistic picture of workload. Our child reacted better once we explained the change in advance instead of announcing it on the day.

    • gv4082

      Good point about asking for the details in writing. I had not thought of that. We revisited the plan after a few months instead of treating it as irreversible. We made the change gradually rather than all at once.

  • jd0583

    Try to let the student own the shortlist while parents own the budget/deadline guardrails. That split worked well for us. Current students gave us more useful detail than the institute presentation. We only reached that conclusion after trying the other approach first.

  • Deepthi K

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. The biggest surprise was that the practical routine mattered more than the option that looked best on paper. Seeing the actual weekly timetable made the trade-off much clearer. We are in Bengaluru, so local logistics may be a little different.

  • [deleted]

    [deleted]

  • mt3306

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. My spouse had a different view initially, so we tried it for a few weeks before deciding. We revisited the plan after a few months instead of treating it as irreversible. We are in Kolkata, so local logistics may be a little different.

    • pa6745

      Did your child take time to adjust, or was the improvement fairly quick? Seeing the actual weekly timetable made the trade-off much clearer. We only reached that conclusion after trying the other approach first.

  • Koushik D

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. We also kept a backup option so one exam did not feel like the whole future. In our house, the practical routine mattered more than the ideal plan.

  • Dinesh K

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. My spouse had a different view initially, so we tried it for a few weeks before deciding. Seeing the actual weekly timetable made the trade-off much clearer. In our house, the practical routine mattered more than the ideal plan.

    • oz2539

      That makes sense. I think consistency is the part we are currently missing. We separated the child's preference from the family budget conversation. I would still test it for a short period before making a long commitment.

    • Bhavana K

      Thanks for saying this. Online advice often makes normal family life sound much more organised than it really is. Current students gave us more useful detail than the institute presentation. We only reached that conclusion after trying the other approach first.

    • ge8016

      Could you share what you would do differently if you were starting again? Seeing the actual weekly timetable made the trade-off much clearer. We made the change gradually rather than all at once.

  • nj6974

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. Current students gave us more useful detail than the institute presentation. Your child's response may be different, but this was our experience.

    • jf5481

      Thanks for saying this. Online advice often makes normal family life sound much more organised than it really is. Seeing the actual weekly timetable made the trade-off much clearer. We made the change gradually rather than all at once.

  • lb7419

    The counsellor was useful only when the session connected interests to concrete courses and next steps. The aptitude report by itself added very little. We also kept a backup option so one exam did not feel like the whole future. Your child's response may be different, but this was our experience.

Add a comment

Share what happened for you. Plain text; be kind and specific.